Wi-Fi Extenders vs Mesh Systems- Pros and Cons

Wi-Fi Extenders vs Mesh Systems- Pros and Cons

Are you in need of boosting your home network system? WiFi extenders vs. mesh systems, which one will work for my home or office?

Well, this is an effortless activity to do. However, most people get stranded at a point where they have to choose between the mesh network and Wi-Fi extenders. Choosing Wi-Fi systems at this point is quite complicating, but once you have the facts, you will make a quick and sound decision.

In this article, I will present facts and comparisons between the mesh network and the Wi-Fi extenders. Such knowledge will enable you to em make the best choices of the most effective method of having a proper system upgrade.

Wi-Fi extenders

A Wi-Fi extender is a device that widens the range of Wi-Fi coverage. At times they may be referred to Wi-Fi boosters or Wi-Fi repeaters. The Wi-Fi extenders allow connectivity through wireless devices and those with cables.

The extenders are kept far from each other. The connections from one extender to another are made through a cable. However, the links to your wireless devices are through wireless targets.

The Wi-Fi extender plays a significant role in ensuring that there is a stable connection maintained by fewer routers.

Pros

  • Less expensive to install
  • Ability to choose the best channel
  • Fast internet speeds

Cons

  • Manual setup
  • Slightly difficult to configure

Mesh Wi-Fi

Mesh Wi-Fi uses several wireless devices to boost your home network. Each method in this network is called a node. A single node gets connected to the internet via Ethernet while the rest use wireless technology to connect.

The outcome of the connection is a single big Wi-Fi area of coverage. Each device connects to the closest node without any interference. Moreover, the nodes are placed at a reasonable, measured distance that ensures that the signal is not lost.

Mesh Wi-Fi ensures that there is a robust and stable connection by connecting many routers within a shorter range hence covering a full area.

Pros

  • Easy to configure
  • Self-organization
  • One unit Wi-Fi

Cons

  • Expensive to upgrade
  • Too many nodes

Similarities between Wi-Fi extenders and mesh Wi-Fi

These two internet range extenders come with various features that make them look alike. The features such as these highlighted below make the range extenders look alike and serving a shared role.

Range extension

Both mesh Wi-Fi and Wi-Fi extenders achieve their primary purpose of extending the network connection. They both reach various corners of your house or offices, giving a perfect service and stable connection to their users.

They fill up space that they cover with an adequate network. The Wi-Fi networks both include a more extensive area offering sufficient support for internet users. Depending on your ISP you can choose the Wi-Fi extender that will work for your home.

For a Wi-Fi extender, you can choose the best AT&T Wi-Fi extender, best Xfinity Wi-Fi extender, and best Spectrum Wi-Fi extender among others.

Ease of installation

Both the mesh Wi-Fi and Wi-Fi extenders are easy to install. For the mesh Wi-Fi you simply need to have one node connected to the source of the internet then pair up the remaining with a simple pair up process. Configurations are done using a mobile app.

Installing the Wi-Fi extenders is also another simple process. You only need to connect the cables from one router to the other. The inputs are apparent, and the outputs are clear too.

Mesh routers like Amazon eero Pro 6, other eero devices, and the best mesh systems are very easy to install.

Compatibility with new devices

Mesh Wi-Fi is highly compatible with the new devices. Installing a new device is straightforward. You only need to add it up to the others and have your network extended. It therefore easily pairs with the latest tools that are added up to the network

Connecting the Wi-Fi extenders is also not a complicated thing. So long as you have the Ethernet cable and your new router has an input, you just plug and do a small configuration, and you will have your internet running.

Removing signal dead zones

Do you have specific points in your house where your internet signal never reaches? Both the mesh Wi-Fi and the Wi-Fi extenders will have your challenge solved. Both range extenders cover specific areas with less technical hitches.

Focusing at one point using any of the range extenders will have your problem solved permanently. However, each one of them has a specific way of addressing such a challenge.

Stability of the network

The two range extenders offer adequate stability to the network. The connection of the mesh ensures that the nodes are close enough to cover most of the area. The Wi-Fi extender also ensures that the is a stable and reliable network for the routers places on a specific distance with an Ethernet cable to keep it well powered and connected.

Configuration

Configuring both the mesh Wi-Fi and Wi-Fi extender is a straightforward process. They both use mobile apps to have them set up.  Moreover, you can leave the Wi-Fi extender on permanent default settings. You can change them easily if need be.

The contrast between mesh and Wi-Fi extenders

Connectivity

The mesh networks use the nodes to connect to each other wirelessly while the Wi-Fi extenders use Ethernet cable to connect.

The initial set up of the mesh Wi-Fi is quite simple. You only need to get a single Ethernet source and connect it to one node. The rest will just be a simple pair up process.

The Wi-Fi extenders use an Ethernet cable to connect one router to the other. The process of connectivity is bulkier because of the wires. You will, therefore, ensure that each router in every room is well connected to the other.

Cost of installation

Wi-Fi extenders are cheaper to install while mesh Wi-Fi is a little bit expensive to install.

When installing some Wi-Fi extenders, you simply add up another router using an Ethernet cable. All you need to do is to buy an Ethernet cable and a router. When installing new routers, you only need a few whose range will easily connect to nest one hence maintaining a well-covered field.

On the contrary, installing the mesh Wi-Fi means merely buying a completely new system to replace the existing one. The installation is costly, as the purchase of the new nodes is not low.  To cover a whole house, you will need several routers that are costly to acquire.

Signal strength

The signal strength of the Wi-Fi extenders is more robust compared to mesh Wi-Fi.

The Wi-Fi extenders simply connect using a cable; hence no signal gets lost on the way. They deliver a powerful and long-range message at all points. Each speaker gives an equal amount of signal as the first one hence quite powerful.

Affection by obstacles is minimal because each router is placed to serve a specific point. It covers the dead points perfectly.

On the contrary, the mesh Wi-Fi has a weaker strength. This is because they depend on one source of connection, which gets extended using nodes. As the nodes connect, they lose signal strength. It gets to a place where it becomes slower. It also gets severely affected by obstacles making it not reach some significant points.

However, mesh Wi-Fi is more stable than Wi-Fi extender.

Number of devices

Mesh Wi-Fi uses the most significant routers as opposed to Wi-Fi extenders, which use limited and specific routers.

For a mesh Wi-Fi to maintain network stability, it needs several devices placed very close to each other. If the internet has to be connected from the house, then outside the home, you will use so many nodes to maintain a quality signal. Too many routers within a short coverage make your house look congested and too occupied.

On the contrary, when using the Wi-Fi extender, you don’t need so many devices to maintain the connection. All you need is an Ethernet cable long enough to connect two routers. It is more specific hence a limited number of devices. It also makes your house look more decent.

Compatibility

The mesh is compatible with its wireless nodes and devices. Once installed, they easily pair hence maintaining a stable connection.

However, this may not be the case with the Wi-Fi extenders. Despite its inability to handle wired connections, it pairs with all its wireless supported devices.

Wi-Fi extenders are not compatible with all routers. Some fail to respond to the signal making it a complicated design to operate. It requires a lot of caution when buying routers so that you do not get an incompatible router.

The extender has to be compatible with the ISP network. For example, you will require a top choice of the AT&T Wi-Fi extender if you use AT&T.

The Ethernet cables may also fail to connect other devices like computers.

Use

Once installed, the mesh Wi-Fi is easier to use than a Wi-Fi extender.

The mesh Wi-Fi uses just a single password to all its nodes instead of a Wi-Fi extender, which may have each router using a specific name and a unique password. They copy the same SSID code and add a number to the end to uniquely identify each router.

As you move to the next sphere of coverage, your devices will need to connect to a new network hence an inconvenience. On the contrary, the mesh Wi-Fi once connected the nodes act as one network and do not need connections.

Performance

The Wi-Fi extender does not receive information at the same time compared to the mesh. Mesh Wi-Fi receives its information at once because of that work as a single unit.

The Wi-Fi extender will, therefore, experience latency and delays, which is not the case with the mesh Wi-Fi. The signal latency delays streaming and gaming. Video conferencing and conversations experience delays hence becoming problematic.

Configuration

Configuration of the mesh Wi-Fi is simple compared to Wi-Fi extender

The mesh Wi-Fi uses a smartphone up to set and configure settings, which is also the case with Wi-Fi extender. However, the Wi-Fi extender involves some manual processes that make the configuration process a little bit complicated. The process not only becomes longer but also confusing.

In contrast, configuring the mesh Wi-Fi is a simple and straightforward touch process.

Putting into consideration the pros and cons of the two Wi-Fi range extenders, they both offer outstanding performance. However, if you have adequate cash, you can consider upgrading your home using the mesh Wi-Fi.

The mesh Wi-Fi is expensive to install and upgrade but has the best features that make it an excellent performer.

If you have a limited budget, you should consider buying the Wi-Fi extender. It is cheaper and has outstanding features too. moreover, it also has the best signal strength that covers all your house and even the dead zones perfectly

It has a specific approach to connection. Once you do the wiring for the cables, they permanently lay there. It is, therefore, a permanent network solution.

Things to consider when upgrading your network system.

Location of the weak signal

When upgrading your Wi-Fi system, you should identify places with a weak signal or not entirely get the internet. Such identification of sites will help you know whether between WiFi extenders vs. mesh systems, which one will serve you best.

Price of upgrading

When upgrading, your budget should give you an ultimate guide. Your budget implications will guide you in choosing whether to buy the costly mesh Wi-Fi or simply to get the less expensive Wi-Fi extender. Having a preexisting Wi-Fi router will also guide you on what compatible routers you will buy, making it more cost-effective.

Usability

It is apparent that the mesh offers a simple Wi-Fi technology to use. It is less complicated to handle and connect. However, the Wi-Fi extender is also not complicated when operated manually. It is simple to use too. you should, therefore, assess the Wi-Fi that suits you best in terms of usability and technology

Size of your house or office

A bigger office will need more extensive Wi-Fi compared to a smaller one. The range of coverage determines the number of routers to be used. This will, in turn, tell you the amount of cost that you are likely to incur to get the Wi-Fi.

This information will, in turn, help you also know which Wi-Fi is convenient with your house or office. Using this information, you can decide between WiFi extenders vs. mesh systems, which one will cover your office adequately.

Final verdict

Knowing the mesh Wi-Fi and the Wi-Fi extender and their pros and cons, you now understand them better. The comparison will put you at a better chance to make a wiser decision when it comes to upgrading your home Wi-Fi system.

Using the description in this article, you can easily decide between Wi-Fi extenders vs. Mesh systems on the one that will work for your home or office.

In addition, in case you prefer something different, you can explore the best router for wide Wi-Fi coverage. These routers will give your home or office complete coverage without the need of using an extender.

Technology Reviewer
Logo
Enable registration in settings - general